Unusual Ways to Die in Old New York

In honor of the Halloween season, we cracked open our “spookiest” records - New York City Coroner’s reports from the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries - to see what we could learn about sudden, untimely death in Old New York.

The Coroner - an official position since before the American Revolution - was charged with assessing sudden, mysterious or suspicious deaths in New York City, and documenting information about the circumstances and individuals involved.

We looked through three volumes of Coroner’s records published by the NYG&B:

• Minutes of Coroner's Proceedings, 1748-1758
• Coroner's Reports, New York City, 1823-1842
• Coroner's Reports, New York City, 1843-1849

These collections are available in our eLibrary - NYG&B members can search by name or browse through the volumes. By the way, as a special offer for this October, new NYG&B members receive a print copy of their choice of Coroner's Reports as a gift. Select your desired choice when filling out the membership form! 

In combing through these records, we learned a lot about the perils our ancestors faced in Old New York City. In short, it was a hazardous place, especially for the lower working classes.

The most unusual deaths we found

Overall, the cases with the most unusual circumstances described by the Coroner fell into two general categories - work accidents and ailments attributed to head-scratching causes.

The former is unsurprising given the time period - New York was a booming city with an unfathomable amount of construction and industrial activity, and workplace safety considerations were non-existent. Structures collapsed, items fell, and back then, even a minor injury by today’s standards could lead to death without proper emergency medical treatment.

Even so, we were surprised at how many seemingly innocuous activities could lead to one’s demise.

In many reports, the Coroner attributed death to causes that seem quite bizarre to the modern reader, but give us a fascinating look at ideas about health, wellness, and plausible causes of death that existed among previous generations.   

Read on for a selection of the most unusual cases we found in these records. We haven't changed or exaggerated any wording - the causes written here are exact transcriptions of what was originally written by the City Coroner. 

Unexpected accidents

“Suffocation in privy” - Henry Zeigler, b. Germany, age 35 (4 Aug. 1838)

“Bursting of a soda fountain” - Lawrence Switzler, b. Germany, age 30 (20 Aug. 1839)

“Wool Accident” - Mary Bracken, b. Ireland, age 61, packed wool for some merchants at 111 Nassau St. where a whole bale of wool fell on her (19 Feb. 1839)

“Gored by a cow. He worked for Mr. Evan Davis at his milk dairy in 15th St” - Griffith Griffiths b. Wales, age unknown (2 July 1843)

“A stove fell on him - had been employed to carry the stove a short distance.” - John Wright, age 50  (29 Nov. 1839)

“A bank of earth of the N.Y. and Erie R.R. falling upon him” - Thomas Cray b. Ireland, age 25 (8 Oct. 1849)

Mysterious maladies

“Visitation of God”- Martha Black b. Ireland, age 60

“Old age and excitement” - Edward Simmons, b. Ireland, age 81 (16 Oct. 1847)

“Drinking cold water when overheated” - Charlotte Sturdevant, b. Albany, age 36 (23 Aug. 1831)

"Inflamation [sic] of the thigh” - John Spears, b. England, age 24. He was a hand on board the sloop Martha Ann, of West Farms, Capt. John Dennison. (3 July 1838)

“Disease from irregular habits” Alice Cullen b. Ireland, age 30 (14 July 1849)

“Cause unclear - He had venereal disease and was discharged from U.S. Service” -  John Bruen, b. New York, a sailor. (7 Mar. 1839)

“Taking tincture of bloodroot” - Edward Carrigan age 47 (15 July 1841)

“By ignorance took 1 oz. of strychnine” - Susanna Shaw, b. County Sligo, Ireland, age 30 (29 Mar. 1843)

Investigate for yourself 

Overall, the Coroner’s reports contain hundreds of cases, and these are just the tip of the iceberg. These fascinating records are well-worth exploring, especially if you’re in the mood for investigating some eerie genealogical material.

And of course, don't forget the immense genealogical value of these records beyond their interesting subject matter. The descriptions, in many cases, mention relatives, associates, and other useful information. 

The records themselves serve as crucial vital record substitutes, which is especially important because New York State vital records can be very difficult to find. And of course, for those who can locate ancestors in these volumes, these records can solve (or create) family mysteries that will remain share-worthy stories for years.

Take a look and let us know if you find anything interesting in the comments!

More Genealogy Reading

• 11 Ways to use the NYG&B website to improve your skills and find ancestors

• Why you need to have your ancestor's New York death certificate

• Researching Irish ancestors in New York State: What you need to know

• 7 resources to get you started with genetic genealogy

• Surprising facts about immigration to New York

• Finding Birth, Marriage, and Death Records in New York State

About the New York Genealogical and Biographical Society

Since 1869, our mission has been to help our thousands of worldwide members discover their family's New York story, and there has never been a better time to join.

The cost of an Individual Annual Membership is less than six dollars a month, and includes the following benefits: 

• Access to over 50 exclusive digital record sets covering the entire state of New York, including the fully searchable archives of The Record. 
• A complimentary subscription to all of Findmypast's North American records, as well as U.K. and Irish Census records.
• Access to hundreds of expert-authored Knowledge Base articles and webinars to help you navigate the tricky New York research landscape. 
• Exclusive discounts and advanced access to conferences, seminars, workshops and lectures to learn more about researching people and places across New York State. 

To learn more or join us, please visit our member benefits page.